Lullaby Loaves

Discover Organic Sourdough Bakes Today.

Located in the North Shore of Staten Island, Lullaby Loaves is a micro cottage bakery that specializes in freshly baked, handcrafted organic sourdough breads. Bakes are a couple days a week and are made to order.

Order Fresh Bakes

Savor Freshly Baked Sourdough

Discover the warmth of home-baked goodness with Lullaby Loaves. Nestled in the heart of Staten Island, our cottage bakery offers an array and variety of fresh, delicious sourdough breads. Perfect for every occasion, our handcrafted products promise to inspire and delight with every bite. Enjoy genuine flavors you won’t forget.

Because of the time and care it takes to make sourdough bread, we require a minimum of 72 hours notice for bread orders.

Custom Cookie Favors

Make your event extra sweet with cookie party favors- individually wrapped with a custom sticker to match your theme and your choice of flavor: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Butterscotch Chip, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, or Peanut Butter Cup. A delicious, personal touch guest will love taking home!

Slide 1 of 3

This might be the best bread I ever had. It's insane. I could eat this entire thing.

- Gerald M.

I've been around the cookie block. Best cookie I've ever had. Outrageous. I expect the holiday orders will be crazy- hopefully, we can get front of the line access.

- Dave Reilly

The bread is incredibly delicious!

- Kara O.

This might be the best bread I ever had. It's insane. I could eat this entire thing.

- Gerald M.

I've been around the cookie block. Best cookie I've ever had. Outrageous. I expect the holiday orders will be crazy- hopefully, we can get front of the line access.

- Dave Reilly

The bread is incredibly delicious!

- Kara O.

This might be the best bread I ever had. It's insane. I could eat this entire thing.

- Gerald M.

I've been around the cookie block. Best cookie I've ever had. Outrageous. I expect the holiday orders will be crazy- hopefully, we can get front of the line access.

- Dave Reilly

The bread is incredibly delicious!

- Kara O.

Wholesome Bakes from the Heart of Staten Island

Lullaby Loaves was born during owner Mindy’s childcare leave. Looking for something creative and fulfilling, she began experimenting with sourdough starter—testing recipes, playing with flavors, and baking loaves filled with love. What started as a simple creative outlet soon became a passion for crafting wholesome bread with minimal ingredients. Today, Lullaby Loaves brings that same warmth and creativity to the community, offering naturally leavened sourdough, flavorful inclusion breads, and sweet treats baked with care.

Nestled in the charming neighborhoods of Staten Island, Lullaby Loaves brings the warmth and aroma of freshly baked goods to your table. Our cottage bakery is dedicated to crafting delicious organic sourdough bread and decidant cookies using time-honored recipes and locally sourced and high quality ingredients.

Freshly Baked Organic Sourdough

Mini Sourdough Loaf

$7+

Our Mini Sourdough Loaves are the perfect size for sharing (or keeping all to yourself). Crafted with organic flour, wild starter, and sea salt, each loaf is naturally fermented for rich flavor and a crisp golden crust. Available classic or with seasonal inclusions like pumpkin, chocolate, or cinnamon—small in size, big in taste. Flavors: -Classic -Dark chocolate chunk -Cinnamon sugar swirl -Italian Parmesan -Cheddar everything -Blueberry lemon zest (seasonal) -pumpkin cinnamon sugar swirl (seasonal)

Mixed flavors

Made to order

Always baked fresh

approx. 400g

72 hours advance notice required

Popular

Classic Organic Sourdough Loaf

$10

Loaf

Our Classic Organic Sourdough is slow-fermented with our wild starter, organic flour, water, and sea salt—nothing else. Naturally leavened over 24 hours, it develops a golden crust, tender crumb, and rich, tangy flavor. Simple, wholesome, and baked fresh for your table.

Made to order

Always baked fresh

Approx. 900g

72 hours advance notice required

Organic sourdough loaf with inclusions

$14+

Loaf

Our Organic Sourdough with Inclusions takes the classic loaf to the next level—handcrafted with organic flour, wild starter, and sea salt, then folded with seasonal additions like roasted pumpkin, dark chocolate, or fragrant herbs. Each loaf is naturally fermented, richly flavorful, and baked to a golden crust. Flavors: -Dark chocolate chunk -Cinnamon sugar swirl -Italian Parmesan -Cheddar everything -Blueberry lemon zest (seasonal) -pumpkin cinnamon sugar swirl (seasonal)

Approx. 900g loaf

Choice of flavor

Made to order

Always baked fresh

72 hour advance notice required

Sourdough Rolls

6 rolls

Our sourdough dinner rolls are soft, pillowy, and naturally leavened with wils starter for a gentle tang. These are perfect with butter, as sandwiches, or a perfect pairing for a dinner party!

Always baked fresh

Made to order

6 sourdough rolls

72 hours advance notice required

Freshly Baked Cookies

$10+

Package

Half and full dozen packs of cookies come with one flavor of choice Flavors: -Chocolate chip -Oatmeal chocolate chip -Milk, peanut butter cup -Butterscotch chip -Oatmeal raisin

Choice of flavor

48 hours advance notice required

Freshly Baked Cookie Boxes

$36+

Box

Assorted cookie boxes start at 24 cookies per box. Flavors: -Chocolate chip -Oatmeal chocolate chip -Milk, peanut butter cup -Butterscotch chip -Oatmeal raisin

Choice of flavor

72 hours advance notice required

Oats of Gold Lactation Cookies

$12

Half dozen

Order

Salted Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies with Butterscotch with Coconut Flakes baked with Brewer's yeast and golden flax meal to support your lactation journey.

48 hours advance notice required '

Cookie Favors

$2.50+

favor

With your choice of cookie flavor, we make personalized party favors for any event. Let us know the theme and we will custom the stickers to match your celebration.

Choice of flavor

Personalized sticker

Packaging

Minimum two weeks advance notice required

Seasonal Breads & Sweets

Mini Sourdough Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Bread

Package

Decedent spiced pumpkin loaf loaded with chocolate chips

Approximately 12oz

48 hours advance notice required

Mini Sourdough Pumpkin Maple Loaves

$9+

Package

Sweetened by the added organic pumpkin purée and organic pure maple syrup, this is delicious on its on own or with added cinnamon swirl or chocolate chips

Approximately 420g

72 hours advance notice required

Party Pack

Mini Sourdough Party Packs (6)

$45+

Package

6 mini loaves (roughly 5-6lbs) of a variety of flavors! Mix and match to meet your needs. Choice of flavors: Classic, Cinnamon Sugar, Dark Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Cup, Italian Parmesan, Everything Cheddar, Sundried tomoato and Mozzeralla, Blueberry Lemon (seasonal + upcharge),

Approximately 6lbs

7 days advance notice required

Choice of flavors

Mini Sourdough Party Packs (3)

$24+

Package

3 mini loaves (roughly 5-6lbs) of a variety of flavors! Mix and match to meet your needs. Choice of flavors: Classic, Cinnamon Sugar, Dark Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Cup, Italian Parmesan, Everything Cheddar, Sundried tomoato and Mozzeralla, Blueberry Lemon (seasonal + upcharge),

Approximately 3lbs

1 weeks advance notice required

choice of flavors

Learn About Our Bakery

What types of baked goods does Lullaby Loaves offer?

Lullaby Loaves specializes organic sourdough.

Where is Lullaby Loaves located?

Lullaby Loaves is located on the North Shore of Staten Island, NY, providing convenient access for local residents seeking freshly baked breads and treats.

Do you offer gluten-free options at Lullaby Loaves?

At this point in time, we do not offer gluten free options.

How can I place an order with Lullaby Loaves?

You can place an order by visiting our website or contacting us directly via email or social media for personalized service.

Does Lullaby Loaves deliver locally within Staten Island?

Yes, we offer local delivery with an upcharge within Staten Island to ensure your baked goods arrive fresh and on time.

Indulge in Freshly Baked Sourdough

Enjoy the comforting taste of organic sourdoughs expertly baked in Staten Island. Savor flavors and aromas that feel like home.

Sourdough Loaves need to be placed at least 72 hours in advance. 
Cookie favors need to be placed at least two weeks in advance
Half, Full dozen cookies can be placed 48 hours in advance
Lactation cookies and cookie assortment boxes need to be placed 72 hours in advance

Order